I must admit that I am coming around to our new Premier Stelmach. I realize that as a Calgarian, Dave Bronconnier has told Calgarians that Stelmach is the devil himself in his petulant fight with Edmonton.
Let me say this. Premier Stelmach is no Ralph Klein. As a member of Calgary Elbow, and Ralph's Lakeview district in particular, that should be an insult. However, I mean that as a compliment. This
article in the Edmonton Journal is exactly what, I believe, Stelmach needs to do. Put some distance between good 'ol boy Klein and himself.
Stelmach has never directly rebuked his predecessor, under whom he obediently served as MLA for 13 years, and cabinet minister for nine.
But as the new premier starts the fall legislature today and prepares for his first election -- whenever he calls it -- his potshots against Klein have become far less subtle. Stelmach has taken pains to assert that he is not the same as the laissez-faire, no-plan, closed-doors ruler he replaced last December.
"Let me be frank," Stelmach said in a televised address last month. "When my government was sworn in 10 months ago, Alberta was not keeping up with the province's growth. Demands on the public services we all rely on ... were outpacing our ability to deliver."
And whereas the old premier said he couldn't give a "tinker's damn" about reviewing oil and gas royalties, the new guy braved the jaws of controversy to design a new royalty regime and claim, in controversially taxpayer-funded ads: "I made a commitment and I delivered."
Later in the same article, we see this statements.
Even the Economist magazine took notice: "Mr. Stelmach finally made his mark," its November issue declared.
McCormick said it's a move reminiscent of Peter Lougheed defying oilpatch warnings and hiking royalties, a marked change from months of pundit comparisons between Stelmach and Harry Strom, the Social Credit farmer-premier who oversaw the demise of his party's 36-year reign.
Let's face it. Stelmach has negotiated revenue agreements with the cities and improved, YES IMPROVED, the royalty regime in Alberta. This royalty regime has rates which fluctuate with oil prices, which is a common sense approach. The terrible aspect of this change is that this required breaking a contract with Syncrude and Suncor. The agreement to 2016 was no negotiated by Stelmach himself but perhaps the agreement should have been respected and applied the changes to new oil sands projects.
Now in
this article, Preston Manning takes issue with the changed royalty regime.
Manning said the royalties plan doesn't take into account the full scope of issues surrounding energy development, including continental energy security, provincial and federal tax implications and environmental costs.
"This would have been a chance to demonstrate that we have a grasp of the big picture," Manning said. "It may be that they do have the competence to do that, but it's not been demonstrated yet, and it wasn't demonstrated last week."
The comments come after Stelmach's royalties strategy was lauded this week by former longtime Alberta premier Peter Lougheed and federal Industry Minister Jim Prentice, who both said the plan strikes the right balance.
(...)
The new framework, set to take effect Jan. 1, 2009, is expected to deliver an additional $1.4 billion in royalties in 2010 -- 20 per cent more than initial projections under the old system -- but falls nearly $500 million short of what was recommended by the panel.
I have worshipped the water that Preston Manning walked on. However, at this point, Albertans have the right to criticize Manning. Stelmach wasn't the front runner in the race for PC leader. If you have such strong opinions about provincial issues, why didn't you care enough to run for the leadership of the PC party? Talk is cheap at this point. Besides, an increased royalty take does not affect continental energy security. Oh man, Manning on Question Period indicated that Stelmach hasn't 'demonstrated the brass' as a leader yet. Quite rich considered Mannings abandonment of Albertans in the PC leadership race.
Premier Stelmach has tackled issues in a common sense straight-forward middle-of-the-road manner that will eventually calm the nerves of Albertans. At least with Stelmach, we're pretty certain that he won't be staggering into a homeless shelter to berate the inhabitants, throwing documents at pages, or demonstrating his wonderful comedic stylings with comments about Belinda Stronach.
As for those conservatives Calgarians who seem to like to categorize Stelmach as a rural bumpkin, I would state 2 things. Firstly, most of these people would hold up Klein as the leader they want. I would not recommend using Klein as a model of urban sophostication. Secondly, where do these people think a lot of current Albertans came from? They aren't all former latte-sipping Vancouverites and Torontonians. Careful with the mud you're slinging boys.
Besides if the federal political pendulum swings back to support the Liberals, Albertans will need a party in Edmonton that they can trust to support Alberta. Albertans are currently feeling free to experiment right now that Harper is PM. That will not last forever.